
- Find the leaking step first: Shopify's conversion reports and abandoned checkouts list, or GA4's begin_checkout, add_shipping_info and add_payment_info events, show where shoppers stop.
- Fix surprise costs first: show shipping, tax and any free shipping threshold on product and cart pages, worded the same way as at checkout.
- Let people buy without an account. On Shopify, requiring sign-in hides accelerated checkout buttons such as Apple Pay in the cart; on WooCommerce, disabling guest checkout hides the WooPay button.
- Turn on express payments and drop checkout fields you do not need before the order.
- Recovery emails come last: Shopify has abandoned checkout emails built in, while WooCommerce needs an extension such as AutomateWoo or MailPoet.
What should you fix first when shoppers leave at checkout?
Find the step where shoppers stop, then fix the causes you control in this order: surprise costs, forced accounts, missing express payments, long forms, missing delivery and returns details, and broken or failing payments. Recovery emails come last, because they only win back part of what a better checkout would have kept.
Some abandonment is normal. In Baymard Institute's survey of online shoppers, 42% had abandoned a cart because they were "just browsing / not ready to buy". No checkout change wins that group back.
How do you find which step is leaking?
Use your own data, not industry averages. On Shopify, the Conversion rate breakdown report shows the path visitors take through store and checkout, and the Conversion rate over time report counts sessions with cart additions, sessions that reached checkout and sessions that completed checkout. A drop before checkout points at the cart page; a drop inside it points at costs, fields or payment.
Then read Orders > Abandoned checkouts. Shopify's abandoned checkouts guide counts a checkout as abandoned once it stays incomplete for more than ten minutes after the shopper gives an email address, and deletes those older than three months, so export what you need. Look for repeated products, destinations and devices.
On WooCommerce, use the GA4 ecommerce events begin_checkout, add_shipping_info, add_payment_info and purchase as steps in a funnel exploration. Confirm each event fires first; a missing event looks exactly like a leak.
Why do shoppers abandon checkout?
With the browsers removed, Baymard's survey figures read like a checklist: 40% left because extra costs (shipping, tax, fees) were too high, 20% found delivery too slow, 19% did not trust the site with their card details, 18% were asked to create an account, 17% found checkout too long or complicated, 17% hit errors or crashes, 13% disliked the returns policy and 10% had a card declined. They are survey answers, not a forecast for your store, but each maps to a setting.
| Cause | Shopify | WooCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Surprise costs | Free shipping minimum on flat rates | Free shipping method with a minimum order amount |
| Forced account | Sign-in requirement off | Enable guest checkout |
| Slow payment entry | Accelerated checkouts | WooPayments express checkouts |
| Failed payments | Decline message on the abandoned checkout | Failed order emails and gateway logs |
| No follow-up | Abandoned checkout emails by Shopify | AutomateWoo or MailPoet |
How do you stop surprise costs at checkout?
Show the full cost before the shopper types an address: a delivery estimate or shipping table on product and cart pages, tax shown the way your market expects, and no fee that first appears at payment.
State any free shipping threshold the same way everywhere. Shopify flat rates let you enter the minimum amount for an order to qualify for free shipping, and the WooCommerce Free shipping method can require a minimum order amount. Watch coupons: unless "Apply minimum order rule before coupon discount" is ticked, WooCommerce checks the minimum after the discount, so a coupon can push a shopper under the threshold and bring shipping back at checkout.
Should shoppers be able to check out without an account?
Yes, for almost every store. Offer the account after the order, not before it.
On Shopify, leave "Require customers to sign in to their account before checkout" unticked in Settings > Checkout. The checkout form options guide notes that when sign-in is required, accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay are not displayed in the online store cart, so a forced login costs you express payments too.
On WooCommerce, the Accounts and Privacy settings include "Enable guest checkout" and an "After checkout" option for creating the account once the order is placed. Subscriptions are the exception, since they always need an account; our WooCommerce subscriptions launch plan covers that.
Which express payment options should you turn on?
Express buttons skip most of the form. Shopify accelerated checkouts cover Shop Pay and providers that offer them, including Apple Pay, Google Pay, Amazon Pay and PayPal, on product pages and at the start of checkout. Shop Pay is included with Shopify Payments and saves the shopper's details for next time.
WooPayments offers five express methods: Amazon Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Link by Stripe and WooPay. Apple Pay and Google Pay are switched on together, and the Apple Pay guide lists checkout, cart and product pages as places the button can appear. Two catches from the compatibility notes: the WooPay button is hidden when guest checkout is disabled, and composite, bookings and Mix and Match products do not show the Apple Pay, Google Pay and Amazon Pay buttons on the product page.
How many checkout fields are too many?
Usually fewer than you have. On the same Baymard page, an ideal checkout can be as short as 12 to 14 form elements, while the average checkout in Baymard's benchmark shows 23.48 by default.
Shopify's checkout form options let you set company name, address line 2 and shipping phone to Don't include, Optional or Required. Shopify warns that a required address line 2 can stop some customers finishing, and a required company name makes Apple Pay and Google Pay customers enter one. On WooCommerce, keep only fields you need before the order: the compatibility guide notes that Apple Pay, Google Pay and Amazon Pay bypass the usual checkout form, so fields added by Checkout Field Editor are not collected on those orders.
What delivery and returns details belong near checkout?
Shoppers want to know when it arrives, whether they can send it back and whether their card is safe. Put a one-line delivery estimate and returns summary on product and cart pages, linked to the full policies. Show contact details a person answers, and payment logos only for methods you accept.
What if checkout breaks or payments fail?
Buy something on a real phone, on mobile data. Shopify hosts its checkout, so problems usually start earlier: a broken cart drawer, a banner over the checkout button, or app scripts slowing pages, which our Shopify technical SEO guide covers. WooCommerce runs on your hosting, so slow servers, cart caching and plugin conflicts matter. Its cart and checkout guide warns that if only gateways incompatible with the Checkout block are active, shoppers see "There are no payment methods available".
Shopify's payment troubleshooting guide says a failed payment usually creates no order; it is recorded as an abandoned checkout whose Message field shows the bank's decline information. Check that test mode is off. The automated recovery email is not sent after a payment processing error, so email those shoppers manually. On WooCommerce, keep the built-in Failed order emails enabled; the customer version explains how to try again.
How do you win back shoppers who still leave?
Shopify has it built in: the "Abandoned checkout emails by Shopify" automation in the Messaging app, with a Send after delay and a link back to the cart. It is not sent if the shopper gave a phone number instead of an email, or if no product in the checkout is still available.
WooCommerce has no abandoned cart reminder among the emails built into the plugin. Woo's own extensions fill the gap: AutomateWoo sends cart reminders at set intervals, and MailPoet offers a series of abandoned cart emails. The AutomateWoo cart guide notes it needs a guest's email before checkout is submitted, and that early capture is off by default and may need cookie consent.
In what order should you work?
- Measure the funnel and read recent abandoned checkouts.
- Remove surprise costs.
- Allow guest checkout.
- Turn on express payments.
- Cut optional fields; add delivery and returns details.
- Fix broken pages and payment errors.
- Switch on recovery emails.
Change one thing at a time and compare equal periods. Our conversion optimisation team runs this review for Shopify stores and, with our ecommerce development team, for WooCommerce.
Frequently asked questions
Should an abandoned checkout email include a discount code?
Not by default. Start with a plain reminder that links back to the cart and answers doubts about delivery and returns. If you test an incentive later, keep it for a later email or higher-value carts, and watch whether regular customers start waiting for codes.
Should we hide the discount code field at checkout?
A prominent empty code box can send shoppers off to search for codes, and some do not come back. Keep it small or collapsed, and apply campaign discounts automatically through links where your platform supports that.
Is a one-page checkout better than a multi-step checkout?
Neither layout wins on its own. The number of fields, early cost visibility and clear error messages matter more. If you change the layout, change nothing else at the same time and judge it by your own funnel data over comparable periods.
How long should we wait before judging a checkout change?
Long enough to collect a meaningful number of orders, across comparable periods, such as the same weekdays with no sale or holiday in only one of them. Smaller stores may need several weeks. Note the date of every change so the reports make sense later.
Can these fixes be made without rebuilding the store?
Usually, yes. Guest checkout, express payments, form fields, free shipping rules and recovery emails are settings or official extensions on both platforms. A rebuild is worth discussing only when the theme or old plugins keep breaking the cart or checkout.
Last updated